An examination of whether the consent users give online is genuinely voluntary, or merely the result of cleverly designed digital interfaces.
Introduction: The Illusion of Choice
Imagine visiting a website to read an article, purchase a product or simply browse its content. Before you can proceed, a familiar pop-up appears on your screen: “We value your privacy. We use cookies to improve your experience.”
You are presented with two options: a prominent button saying “Accept All Cookies” and a smaller, less noticeable option to manage your preferences. Sometimes, rejecting cookies requires navigating through multiple settings, whereas accepting them takes just one click. In other instances, the website repeatedly prompts you to reconsider your decision until you eventually give in.
At first glance, this may appear to be an ordinary feature of website design. However, it raises a much more fundamental legal question: If a user is subtly pushed towards accepting cookies, can that acceptance truly be considered consent?
In today’s digital economy, cookies are no longer limited to remembering login details or keeping items in shopping carts. They can be used to track browsing behaviour, analyse user preferences, create advertising profiles and monitor individuals across websites. Consequently, the manner in which websites obtain permission to collect and process personal data has become an important aspect of digital privacy.
Cookies are small text files that a website stores on a user’s browser or device when they visit a website. They help the website remember information about the user, such as login credentials, language preferences, items added to a shopping cart, browsing activity and session details, so that the user does not have to enter the same information repeatedly. Cookies may also be used by third parties for advertising, analytics and tracking user behaviour across websites. Broadly, cookies can be classified as first-party cookies, created by the website being visited, and third-party cookies, created by external services integrated into that website. From a data privacy perspective, cookies become important because certain cookies collect or process
Third-party cookies are small text files placed on a user’s browser by a domain other than the website the user is currently visiting. These cookies are generally created by external service providers whose technologies are integrated into the website, such as Google Analytics, Meta (Facebook), advertising networks, social media plugins or marketing platforms.
Example: Suppose you visit an online clothing website. The website uses a Meta advertising pixel to understand visitor behaviour. When you browse a particular product, a third-party tracking mechanism may record information about your visit. If you subsequently visit another website that also uses the same advertising network, the network may be able to recognise your browser and use the collected information to build an advertising profile or show you advertisements relating to the product you previously viewed.
The European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) places consent at the centre of its data protection framework. However, it does not recognise consent merely because a user has clicked an acceptance button. Consent must be freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous. This distinction exposes a growing concern in digital privacy: the difference between a user making a genuine choice and a website designing that choice for them.
Understanding the legal framework: What does GDPR say about consent?
The GDPR establishes a comprehensive framework for protecting individuals’ personal data and regulating how organisations collect, use and process such information. One of its central principles is that individuals should retain meaningful control over their personal data.
Article 4(11)[1] of the GDPR defines consent as any freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication of the data subject’s wishes, through which they signify agreement to the processing of their personal data by a statement or a clear affirmative action.
This definition establishes four essential requirements:
Freely given: Individuals must have a genuine choice and must not be pressured, manipulated or placed at a disadvantage for refusing consent.
Specific: Consent must relate to clearly identified purposes. A general acceptance of all data-processing activities cannot automatically authorise every possible use of personal data.
Informed: Users must understand what information is being collected, why it is being collected and how it will be used.
Unambiguous: Consent must result from a clear affirmative action. Silence, inactivity or pre-ticked boxes cannot be treated as valid consent.
Article 7[2] further strengthens these requirements by placing obligations on organisations seeking consent. In particular, Article 7(1) requires the data controller to demonstrate that the data subject has consented to the processing of their personal data. Article 7(3) also recognises the individual’s right to withdraw consent at any time and requires withdrawal to be as easy as giving consent.
These provisions are particularly significant in the context of cookie banners. A website cannot simply rely on the fact that a visitor clicked an acceptance button. It must be able to demonstrate that the consent obtained satisfies the legal requirements under the GDPR.
However, an important distinction must be made: cookie regulation is not governed by the GDPR alone. Article 5(3) of the EU ePrivacy Directive regulates the storage of information, or access to information already stored, on a user’s terminal equipment. It generally requires informed consent unless a narrow exception applies, such as where the cookie is strictly necessary to provide a service explicitly requested by the user.
Where cookies also involve the processing of personal data, the GDPR applies alongside the ePrivacy framework. Therefore, compliance with one does not automatically establish compliance with the other.
Dark Patterns: When Website Design Manipulates Consent
One of the most concerning developments in digital privacy is the increasing use of what are commonly known as dark patterns or deceptive design patterns.
Dark patterns refer to interface designs that influence users into making decisions they might not otherwise make, often by exploiting their habits, limited attention or lack of awareness. In the context of cookie banners, these designs can subtly encourage users to accept tracking technologies while making it unnecessarily difficult to refuse them.
Some common examples include:
a. The Accept-All Advantage
A website displays a large, brightly coloured “Accept All” button while the option to reject non-essential cookies is presented in a smaller font, a less visible colour or a secondary settings menu.
The design creates an imbalance between the available choices, making acceptance appear to be the easiest or most obvious option.
b. The Privacy Maze
Users can accept all cookies with a single click, but rejecting them requires navigating through multiple layers of settings, toggling individual preferences and saving several selections.
This deliberately increases the effort required to exercise privacy rights.
c. The Cookie Wall
Certain websites prevent visitors from accessing their content unless they agree to accept cookies or tracking technologies.
For example, a user may be required to accept advertising and analytical cookies before reading an online article, even when those cookies are not necessary to provide the requested content.
d. Continuous Prompting
Even after a user rejects non-essential cookies, the website repeatedly displays consent requests, encouraging them to reconsider their decision.
Such repeated prompts may gradually pressure users into accepting cookies simply to avoid further interruptions.
The European Data Protection Board (EDPB), in its Guidelines 03/2022 on deceptive design patterns in social media platform interfaces, recognises several such practices, including overloading users with information, hiding privacy-related choices, emotionally steering decisions and obstructing the exercise of data protection rights.
Although these guidelines specifically address social media platforms, the underlying principles offer useful guidance when assessing manipulative interface designs in other digital environments.
The EDPB’s Cookie Banner Taskforce has also examined problematic cookie-banner practices. Its report highlights that website owners should not design banners in a manner that gives users the impression that consent is compulsory or clearly pushes them towards accepting cookies.
The concern, therefore, is not simply about the appearance of a website. It is about whether the design interferes with an individual’s ability to make a genuinely independent decision.
What Have the Courts Said? Understanding the Planet49 Judgment
The legal position concerning cookie consent received significant clarification in Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband e.V. v Planet49 GmbH (Case C-673/17), decided by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on 1 October 2019.
The case concerned an online promotional lottery in which participants were presented with a pre-ticked checkbox indicating their agreement to the storage of cookies on their devices. Users were required to actively remove the tick if they did not wish to consent.
The central question was whether consent obtained through a pre-selected checkbox could satisfy the legal requirements for valid consent.
The CJEU held that consent obtained through a pre-ticked checkbox was not valid. It clarified that consent requires active behaviour and that a user must take a deliberate step to indicate agreement. Mere inactivity or failure to untick a pre-selected option cannot constitute consent.
The Court also emphasised that users must be provided with clear information about the duration of cookies and whether third parties may have access to them.
The significance of this judgment extends beyond pre-ticked boxes. It reinforces the principle that consent must reflect an individual’s actual intention rather than an assumption made by the organisation collecting the data.
In other words, the absence of objection cannot be treated as the presence of consent.
This judgment is particularly relevant to modern cookie banners, where websites may attempt to obtain consent through default settings, ambiguous buttons or interface designs that discourage rejection.
The Regulatory Position: What Makes a Cookie Banner Compliant?
The legal framework does not prohibit websites from using cookies. Rather, it requires organisations to ensure that the use of cookies complies with applicable data protection and privacy requirements.
A compliant cookie banner should, at a minimum, incorporate the following safeguards:
1. Equal prominence of choices: Accepting and rejecting non-essential cookies should be presented in a clear and accessible manner. Rejecting cookies should not be deliberately made more difficult than accepting them.
2. Prior consent: Non-essential cookies requiring consent should not be placed before the user has provided valid consent.
3. Granular consent: Users should be able to choose which categories of cookies they wish to accept, rather than being forced to accept all categories collectively.
4. Clear and transparent information: Websites should explain the purposes of different cookies, the parties involved in processing the information and the relevant retention periods.
5. Easy withdrawal: Users should be able to change their preferences or withdraw consent without having to navigate through complicated settings.
6. No pre-selected options: Non-essential cookies should not be activated through pre-ticked boxes or default settings that assume the user’s agreement.
These safeguards are consistent with the GDPR’s principles of fairness, transparency and accountability under Article 5[3], alongside the consent requirements under Articles 4(11)[4] and 7[5].
Furthermore, Article 25[6], which deals with data protection by design and by default, requires organisations to incorporate appropriate data protection measures into their systems and processes. This obligation is particularly relevant to cookie banners because privacy compliance should be considered during the design of the interface itself, rather than introduced as an afterthought.
A website should not merely provide users with a theoretical opportunity to reject cookies; it should ensure that the rejection mechanism is genuinely accessible and effective.
Who Is Accountable? The Responsibility of Website Owners
An important question arises when websites rely on third-party Consent Management Platforms (CMPs) or external service providers to manage cookie preferences.
Can a website owner avoid responsibility by claiming that the cookie banner was designed or supplied by an external technology provider?
The answer is no.
Under the GDPR, the data controller remains responsible for ensuring that personal data is processed lawfully. Outsourcing the technical management of cookie preferences does not automatically transfer the controller’s legal responsibility.
Organisations must therefore ensure that their cookie management systems are appropriately configured, that users’ preferences are respected and that non-essential tracking does not take place without the necessary consent.
The Dutch Data Protection Authority, for instance, has specifically emphasised that organisations remain responsible for ensuring that their cookie banners comply with applicable legal requirements, even where they use an external consent management platform.
Failure to obtain valid consent may expose organisations to regulatory investigations, corrective measures and administrative fines under Article 83 of the GDPR, depending on the nature and seriousness of the infringement.
This demonstrates that cookie compliance is not simply a technical issue to be delegated to website developers. It is an organisational responsibility that requires coordination between legal, compliance, marketing and technology teams.
The Way Forward: From Formal Consent to Meaningful Choice
The growing concern surrounding cookie banners demonstrates that having a consent mechanism is not necessarily the same as respecting user autonomy.
A website may technically provide an option to reject cookies, but if that option is deliberately concealed, difficult to locate or unnecessarily complicated to exercise, the question of whether consent was freely given becomes questionable.
The EDPB’s guidance on deceptive design patterns makes it clear that organisations must consider how interface design influences users’ decisions concerning their personal data. Similarly, the European Commission’s guidance on valid consent emphasises that individuals must be able to refuse or withdraw consent without being placed at a disadvantage.
Going forward, organisations should move beyond a checkbox-based approach to privacy compliance and adopt a more user-centric model. This means designing cookie banners that provide equally accessible choices, communicate information in understandable language and respect users’ decisions without repeatedly pressuring them.
Ultimately, the effectiveness of data protection legislation should not be measured merely by the number of consent buttons displayed on a website. It should be measured by whether individuals are genuinely able to exercise control over their personal information.
Conclusion: Is It Really Consent If You Were Never Given a Fair Choice?
The fundamental purpose of the GDPR is to protect individuals’ personal data and ensure that organisations process such information responsibly. However, when website interfaces are designed to encourage acceptance rather than facilitate informed decision-making, the very purpose of obtaining consent is undermined.
Consent should represent an individual’s willingness to permit the processing of their personal data, not their willingness to escape an inconvenient pop-up or navigate through endless privacy settings.
The distinction between accepting and rejecting cookies should therefore be a matter of personal choice, not interface manipulation.
After all, clicking “Accept All” may take only a second, but the consequences of that decision may extend far beyond a single browsing session. If a website designs the choices, controls their visibility and influences the outcome, one must ask: is the user really exercising control over their data, or is the website exercising control over the user’s choice?
-Anwesha, Associate, Ductus Legal
[1] https://gdpr-info.eu/art-4-gdpr/
[2] https://gdpr-info.eu/art-7-gdpr/
[3] https://gdpr-info.eu/art-5-gdpr/
[4] https://gdpr-info.eu/art-4-gdpr/